#Internet Governance vs #Governments #Brexit #politics #privacy #security #UKIGF16 #standards @UKIGF @Nominet @IGF

Who rules the internet and how? These were the topics of this day with this agenda.

  • Governance vs Government seems to be the issue!
  • That means Public Interest and Public Policy vs Vested Interests…!

The first person I spoke with introduced me to the Individual Users Association and I mentioned my recent experiences:

  • suffering from what used to be a ‘sexy’ domain name but has become unnecessarily expensive;
  • not suffering from HOSTING or CLOUD companies when they go bust;
  • for we’re ‘governed’ by what’s dishonest with our money system – not the myth of governments… But who understands that? And who wants to know?
  1. The introduction was given by Baroness Fritchie, Chair, Nominet. She started by pointing out one of the cultural UK-US differences: how people begin to occupy chairs in an empty room…
  2. The US version of Internet Governance was explained by Lawrence Strickling who stressed democratic and ‘multi-stakeholder’ governance which requires CONSENSUS based on SHARED DECISIONS.
    • Here’s the NetMundial Stakeholder Statement.
    • It appears that e-democracy is more likely to happen than the fake political democracy we’re experiencing, for economic democracy is what we’re truly lacking. However, mind the gap between the quality not just the geography of stakeholders:
      • individuals and organisations
      • NGOs and SMEs
      • local, regional, national and multi-national corporations
      • governments of large and small economies…
    • Prosperity, innovation and free expression are the noble ideals with which Lawrence Strickling ended his talk!
  3. Ed Vaizey MP, Former Minister for Culture,Communications and Creative Industries was next.

The second session had a panel with Charlotte Holloway as chair, the Brexit Policy Coordinator from techUK: Brexit, what next for UK internet policy?

  1. Jamie Bartlett from the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media @JamieJBartlett
  2. Malcolm Harbour CBE, former Conservative MEP
  3. Chris Francis from SAP, the German software company @chrisfrancis1

A BCS [British Computer Society] member pointed out that Euro-DIG is the UK/EU forum for internet governance.

I got so excited that I proposed as solution to follow every face-to-face meeting with an online forum. I wonder who’ll make it happen? After all, everybody knows best… and few listen… Online consultations have a ‘top-down approach’ built in!

I also mentioned that I built a design for Digital Bidding after the Crown Commercial Services [CCS] came to techUK for user research.

The third session was chaired by Seb Payne (FT Comment Editor) @SebastianEPayneWhat is the impact of the internet on political debate?

  • are we replacing people with algorithms?
  1. Toni Cowan-Brown (UK/EU leader for NationBuilder [software for leaders]) @ToniCowanBrown
    • yes, the internet is ‘good’, as it gives people the Power to Organise;
    • it’s about being SMART about the data you’ve got;
    • we would be STUPID, if we didn’t use the tools at our disposal!
  2. Carl Miller (Research Director for Centre for the Analysis of Social Media, Demos @Demos
    • algorithms are the rising towers of our times!
    • ultimate decision making is here!
    • the professional journalist is on his way out!
    • ‘digital literacy’ is becoming urgent for democracy!
  3. Dan Hodges (Mail on Sunday) @DPJHodges
    • clicking or voting – is that the question?
    • if you believe that Hillary was into satan, you wouldn’t have voted for her!

Should there be legislation on petitions like Change.org and 38 Degrees?

  • regulating campaigns is one thing – influencing social media another!
  • we don’t know what should be permissible!
  • even if implement laws, how do we enforce them?

After lunch, Russell Haworth, CEO of @Nominet was speaking.

Then Rt Hon Matt Hancock MP, Minister for Digital and Culture @MattHancockMP

  • is there are a need for governance?
  • it is an invention by humanity for humanity!

Subsequent discussions were on privacy and security which I just happen not to get excited about, as they are fear-based.

And now the real thing: An internet for children and young people

Baroness Shields, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Internet Safety & Security.

After a MOST FASCINATING Youth Panel, this wrap up with

For me, there is now an obvious TO DO list for those who listened to the young people and who can make it happen:

  • create STANDARDS for ‘reporting’ and closing accounts on social media;
  • I have suffered myself from Facebook, Twitter, Google Drive, Change.org, YouTube and Wix.com;

Who will come to our rescue?

About Sabine Kurjo McNeill

I'm a mathematician and system analyst formerly at CERN in Geneva and became an event organiser, software designer, independent web publisher and online promoter of Open Justice. My most significant scientific contribution is www.smartknowledge.space
This entry was posted in Governance, Governments, Internet, techUK. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s